Data Loading...
COPPICE SILVICULTURE: SOME ALTERNATIVES AND APPLICATIONS Flipbook PDF
COPPICE SILVICULTURE: SOME ALTERNATIVES AND APPLICATIONS Ralph D. Nyland Department of Forest and Natural Resources Mana
457 Views
209 Downloads
FLIP PDF 6.65MB
COPPICE SILVICULTURE: SOME ALTERNATIVES AND APPLICATIONS
Ralph D. Nyland Department of Forest and Natural Resources Management SUNY College of Environmental Science and Forestry Syracuse, NY 13210
Nyland – 2009 All rights reserved Use of all or parts of these class notes prohibited without express consent of Ralph D. Nyland
Background reading: Chapter 9, in Nyland, R.D. 2002. Silviculture: Concepts and Applications. Waveland Press. Long Grove. IL. 2ed. Sources cited: Aldrich 1963 ArborGen, LCC. 2009. FlexStand System Guide. ArborGen LCC, Summerville SC. Christersson, L., L. Sennerby-Forsse, and L. Zsuffa. 1993. The role and significance of woody biomass plantations in Swedish agriculture. For. Chron, 69(6):687-693. Fowells, H.A. 1965. Silvics of Forest Trees of the United States. US For. Serv. Agric Handbk. 271. Hammill and Moran 1986 Hawley, R.C. 1937. The Practice of Silviculture. John Wiley & Sons, Inc. NY. 3ed. Hawley, R.C., and D.M. Smith 1954. The Practice of Silviculture. Wiley. NY. 6ed. Matthews, J.D. 1991. Silvicultural systems. Oxford Univ. Press., Oxford. Patton, D.R. 1992. Wildlife Habitat Relationships in Forested Ecosystems. Timber Press. Portland, OR. Porter, W.F. 1987. Integrating wildlife management with even-aged timber systems. Pp. 319-337. in Managing Northern Hardwoods. R.D. Nyland, (Ed.). SUNY Coll. Environ. Sci,. and For., Fac. For. Misc. Publ No. 13 (ESF 87-02) Soc. Sm. For. Publ. No. 87-03.
1
Consider an example …
Aspen silviculture … …with attention to wildlife (grouse) habitat management
Natural ranges for aspen and ruffed grouse overlap …
2
Grouse benefit from aspen stands at different stages of development …
… feeding on catkins and buds US Forest Service
… and using dense stands for cover and other life essentials
3
… also, aspen stands may have high volumes of good fiber suitable to many uses
… and we can regenerate them over large areas readily by coppice methods
4
But note this … - while good sites produce high volumes - poor sites and overmature stands have limited commodity potential
Overmature and decadent poor for commodities …
… also not necessarily great for ruffed grouse
5
So what age for 5000/acre
Best conditions for grouse ...
This stand has high potential as grouse habitat ...
6
What age for 20 feet tall
18 ft
12 ft
6 ft
7
Note this … … how habitat quality shifts with stand age
Porter 1987
... about half a century
8
Also an interspersion of condition classes best …
Porter 1987
… with different conditions in close proximity
… interspersion of requisite conditions over space and time
9
And close proximity means …
… within 500 feet
... a balance of age classes across the landscape
Not a goal with aspen
≤ 500 ft Adapted from Patton 1992
10
Stacy McNulty 2000
... establishing different age classes in close proximity
… but not likely to this extreme
11
… probably more like this
... well suited to mechanized harvesting
12
... and fiber production goals
US Forest Service
… clearfelling the copse to establish a new age class
13
US Forest Service
… relying on root suckers to restock the stand
US Forest Service
… with this outcome (after 11 years)
14
… but how to know when to call a stand mature
The culmination of m.a.i.
15
A reasonable match …
Peak m.a.i.
Porter 1986
... within the maximum targeted time
... melding fiber production using coppice methods, with maintenance of good habitat for ruffed grouse
16
Now back to a consideration of coppice silviculture …
… in general … as well as making it suitable for coppicing aspen with wildlife habitat management
Coppice system advantages … SIMPLE … - certain regeneration - high level volume production - short rotations, with quick payoffs (e.g., volume and grouse with aspen) - cutting area any size and shape - species composition predictable - few health risks with short rotations
17
A good scheme for fiber production … … and grouse habitat management
Coppice system disadvantages … - small diameter products (mostly) - useful with few species (hardwoods) - frequent site disturbance with short rotations - yields little sawtimber - aesthetically unpleasant (the reproduction method) - grazing / browsing must be excluded - shoots arising after late summer cutting susceptible to frost damage
18
... and if by sprouting, you must deal with the clumps
Consider an alternative …
19
Consider an alternative …
Coppice with standards … … selected trees (perhaps of seed origin) left to grow to large size
An alternative …
START STANDARD
STANDARD
STANDARD
… keep selected trees at uniform and wide spacing
20
Coppice with standards … … selected trees (perhaps of seed origin) left to grow to large size … with coppice growth maintained beneath them
… then coppice the rest
Like this after the cutting …
… leaving only the standards
21
An alternative …
Leading to a 2-aged stand
… as the coppice shoots develop
START STANDARD
STANDARD
STANDARD
.. or like this with oaks
From: Matthews 1991
22
… coppice with standards … in aspen
… a two-aged stand
23
Second entry …
CUT ALL EXCEPT SELECTED NEW STANDARDS Same process repeated through time…
STANDARD
STANDARD
STANDARD
… as a new age class develops by coppice growth
Or as a new approach for coppice-with-standards …
(Standard) (Coppice)
… perhaps implemented as suggested by ArgorGen with its FlexStand strategy
ArborGen FlexStand Schematic
ArborGen 2009
24
e this … something lik … repeated inde
finitely
Or have standards of multiple ages …
… go first to coppice with standards
… each time keeping some of the old standards, plus adding new standards from the understory growth
To get this … From Hawley 1935
25
Called COMPOUND COPPICE … … producing an uneven-aged stand
An alternative …
COMPOUND COPPICE
26
Hawley and Smith 1954
… like this from above
Coppice with standards … Silvicultural requirement (historic) … - the STANDARDS should be fast-growing species … may mean shade-intolerant ones - the coppice UNDERWOOD may need to be at least moderately shade tolerant
27
Or …
Or … … keep the standards at only rather wide spacing
... like this to improve light in the understory
28
To increase the number of standards … - retain existing standards as a seed source … if old enough to produce seed - clean to keep young potential standards free to grow - beat up the stand (reinforcement planting) … but plant large seedlings as a wide spacing - thin selected coppice clumps to a single stem … and keep the favored sprout for multiple rotations as a seed source
... periodically establishing some new trees to become future standards
29
... or deciding how to convert sprout clumps to single-stem standards for the future … or with some species just accepting a few sprout clumps of low origin
Now an entirely different kind of coppice system …
… for BIOMASS PRODUCTION
30
Note the advantage of willow …
Christersson et al. 1993
… as a mini-rotation biomass crop
When planted at close spacing … ... and managed for mini-rotation periods
31
T.A. Volk
... started from unrooted cuttings
32
D. Robison
Swedish double-row planting method …
Coppiced after the first year to promote vigorous sprouting from the stools …
... with the shrub willows producing multiple vigorous sprouts after the 1st-year cutting
33
... like this
... and rapid growth
34
But when to end the rotation ...
Nissen 2001
… regenerating the copse at the culmination of m.a.i. for biomass
… with a harvester like this one
35
The cutter head …
Producing chips like this for biofuels …
36
... and cutting low stools
... they will sprout again for another rotation
37
... providing repeated crops at short rotations
... woody biomass (at least 10 dry tons/ac/yr)
38
After Nissen 2010
Should we clone it … … if it had antlers, I’d do something
39